That's the possum favorite brand here. I think they like creamy and crunchy about the same, LOL
Around here those possums will eat anything that is in the trap. Peanut butter seems to be their favorite. I use that primary for possums.
I had a live trap set out in one of those high dollar subdivisions for a fox and I placed a fresh dead mouse in the trap that night, came back the next morning and the dead mouse was gone and a ole possum in the trap.
I think if you threw a dirty diaper in a live trap you'll catch a dang ole dirty possum.